Supporters of police officer killed in 2022 tell The U.S. Sun why they are confident justice will be served
ONE dead police officer, two furious camps of supporters, and a flood of sickening, bitter online hate that’s threatening to destroy lives.
The small Massachusetts suburb of Canton, just 20 miles south of Boston, will hold its breath this weekend as the tumultuous Karen Read murder trial enters a decisive stage.
DRAMATIC ENDING
Closing arguments were heard Friday, as Read fights a second degree murder charge over the January 29, 2022 death of her boyfriend, Boston police officer John O’Keefe.
The jury were sent for deliberation after eight weeks in Norfolk Superior Court and will return on Monday with a decision expected imminently.
She also faced charges for driving drunk when the fatal incident occurred, along with fleeing the scene after allegedly causing O’Keefe’s death.
He was found dead in the snow outside a private party at the house of Brian Albert, a retired Boston cop and lifelong Canton resident.
What began as a tragic incident has spiraled into one of the most polarizing legal battles in recent state history.
And at the heart of the drama —played out daily via live courthouse streams — is a vicious tug-of-war between two increasingly hostile groups of observers, each convinced they know where justice truly lies.
The U.S. Sun spoke last month with Read supporter Rita Lombardi, who described how the town has been “torn apart,” with relatives and friends turning on her over her defense of the accused woman.
She even said her lawn had been vandalized with bleach filled balloons which were allegedly thrown onto her property.
Theories of police misconduct have circulated widely, with critics pointing fingers at investigators for alleged interference and a lack of transparency.
Read’s defense team alleges that O’Keefe, who was the legal guardian of his niece and nephew after their parents died, actually entered Albert’s house, only to be beaten, possibly bitten by a dog, then hauled out into the snow.
FURIOUS COUNTER-CLAIM
But O’Keefe’s loved ones argue that Read acted out of malice after a night of heavy drinking, insisting she is solely responsible for the 46-year-old’s death by reversing into him.
Read, who chose not to testify in either trial, has since become outspoken in the media.
She’s spoken to reporters outside court, appeared on TV, sat down for a Vanity Fair interview, and participated in a true-crime docuseries — all while maintaining her innocence.
But in court, prosecutors played a pivotal moment from her October 2024 Dateline interview, where Read appeared to waver. “I didn’t think I hit him,” she said in the clip. “But could I have clipped him… knocked him out… and in drunkenness and in the cold, he didn’t come to again?”
“She was drunk, she hit him and left him to die” said prosecutor Hank Brennan, who is best known for defending James “Whitey” Bulger, the notorious mob boss, in his closing statement Friday, where he described their two year relationship as “toxic.”
“It was crumbling. The discontent was palpable.”
The late officer also has a vocal group of backers on X, many of whom remain anonymous out of fear of retaliation — but are convinced of Read’s guilt.
The U.S. Sun spoke to two O’Keefe supporters who requested anonymity due to ongoing harassment.
They claim some Read advocates have contacted their employers and launched smear campaigns that spilled into their professional and personal lives.
“We get death threats,” said one supporter. “People stalk and dox us. They post old photos and dig through every account you’ve ever had. The harassment is unreal.”
The unnamed woman said the online chaos reminds her of the Delphi murders, where amateur sleuths posted graphic crime scene images of two slain Indiana teens.
The twisted man behind one of America’s most haunting child murder cases was unmasked not in court—but online, as chilling footage of his confession exploded across social media.
Richard Allen, the Indiana pharmacy worker who butchered two schoolgirls on a wooded trail, is now serving 130 years behind bars—but it’s the internet, not the justice system, that truly blew this case wide open.
The 2024 trial ended with Allen handed the maximum sentence for murdering 13-year-old Abigail “Abby” Williams and 14-year-old Liberty “Libby” German, who vanished while hiking in Delphi back in 2017.
But it wasn’t until after the courtroom drama wrapped that the most disturbing evidence began surfacing online — uncensored, unfiltered, and horrifying.
Clips from Libby’s phone — captured just moments before her death—and video of Allen breaking down and confessing during a police interrogation have been shared across X, TikTok, and YouTube in recent months.
Viewers were stunned to see the killer’s face twitch and crumble as he admitted to the murders, confirming years of whispers and theories that had dominated true crime forums and Reddit threads.
The footage, originally shown in court, was leaked or obtained through media pressure — and once it hit the web, it spread like wildfire.
“No matter what the verdict is, someone died.That’s the real tragedy here.
While there is no smoking gun confession in this case, critics say social media has done more to expose the truth than the authorities ever did, while the victims’ families wrestle with grief all over again as the killer’s confession plays out on loop for millions.
WILD THEORIES
In Canton, accusations have flown around about YouTubers profiting off false narratives. One blogger, known as Turtleboy, has been indicted on 16 counts including witness intimidation.
The woman we spoke to estimates “500 to 1,000 people” are involved in targeted harassment.
“It’s terrible. The same thing happened in Delphi. People are attacking witnesses and families. Defense teams have worked directly with TikTokers and YouTubers to push propaganda,” she said.
“We’re tired of seeing victims’ families get dragged. A group of us is working to name and call out the people spreading lies for clicks.”
She also noted that while some O’Keefe supporters have been physically stalked, they’ve avoided retaliation—focusing instead on courtroom updates.
“To me, it’s obvious. You’d have to suspend all logic to think this wasn’t a domestic violence drunk hit-and-run,” she said. “It’s shocking how badly we treat male victims. He was trapped in a coercive relationship.”
The public attention has overwhelmed Canton. Last year’s street demonstrations during the first trial, she said, were “humiliating.”
“It’s an embarrassing circus,” she added.
Another O’Keefe supporter from Massachusetts said he’s been forced to speak anonymously behind a parody account.
He told the U.S. Sun the case has “divided the community” and made it nearly impossible to talk about openly.
He also pointed to recent anti-police sentiment in cities like Los Angeles as a factor in the case.
“People are quick to believe police are hiding something,” said the man, who posts under @cccuomo870. “Whether that’s true or not, the fact that so many think it is shows how far trust has eroded.”
Source : https://www.the-sun.com/news/14475310/karen-read-murder-case-john-okeefe-delphi-murders/