Poland’s constitutional court has overturned plans to recognize same-sex marriages that took place in other EU member states. This defies an order from the EU’s top court and could set up a clash on the matter.
The government in Warsaw had been moving to accommodate a ruling from the Court of Justice of the European Union saying that majority-Catholic Poland, which does not permit same-sex marriage domestically, must at least recognize unions contracted elsewhere in the EU.
The unanimous ruling could set up a power struggle between Poland’s top court and that of the 27-member bloc.
What did Poland’s Constitutional Tribunal rule?
The court said in a statement on Tuesday that the judgment was unanimous and final and that EU same-sex marriages could not be copied into the country’s civil registry as previously planned.
It said that the plans for the “preparation and issuance of certified copies concerning unions contracted abroad that do not constitute a union between a woman and a man,” were “inconsistent with Article 92, Paragraph 1, in conjunction with Article 18 of the Constitution of the Republic of Poland.”
Article 18 of the constitution reads as follows: “Marriage, being a union of a man and a woman, as well as the family, motherhood and parenthood, shall be placed under the protection and care of the Republic of Poland.”
In other words it both designates marriage as heterosexual in nature and as part of Poland’s jurisdiction.
Article 92, Paragraph 1 meanwhile states that regulations should be specified by “the organs specified in the Constitution.”
The court did not elaborate on its reasoning in its short statement, but this seemed to suggest its judges found that the European court order encroached on Poland’s authority to set its family and marriage policies.
Poland’s highest court, the Constitutional Tribunal on Tuesday overturned a law that would have led to the legal recognition of same-sex spouses who married in other EU member states and subsequently moved to Poland.
The government in Warsaw had been moving to accommodate a ruling from the Court of Justice of the European Union saying that majority-Catholic Poland, which does not permit same-sex marriage domestically, must at least recognize unions contracted elsewhere in the EU.
The unanimous ruling could set up a power struggle between Poland’s top court and that of the 27-member bloc.
What did Poland’s Constitutional Tribunal rule?
The court said in a statement on Tuesday that the judgment was unanimous and final and that EU same-sex marriages could not be copied into the country’s civil registry as previously planned.
It said that the plans for the “preparation and issuance of certified copies concerning unions contracted abroad that do not constitute a union between a woman and a man,” were “inconsistent with Article 92, Paragraph 1, in conjunction with Article 18 of the Constitution of the Republic of Poland.”
Article 18 of the constitution reads as follows: “Marriage, being a union of a man and a woman, as well as the family, motherhood and parenthood, shall be placed under the protection and care of the Republic of Poland.”
In other words it both designates marriage as heterosexual in nature and as part of Poland’s jurisdiction.
Article 92, Paragraph 1 meanwhile states that regulations should be specified by “the organs specified in the Constitution.”
The court did not elaborate on its reasoning in its short statement, but this seemed to suggest its judges found that the European court order encroached on Poland’s authority to set its family and marriage policies.
Source: https://www.dw.com/en/poland-top-court-rejects-recognizing-eu-same-sex-marriages/a-78146379
