
Oat milk in the morning latte, a coconut yogurt at lunch, a cashew-based cheese on the dinner board: each swap feels like a small win for health and the planet. Yet trading dairy for plant-based alternatives quietly strips away iodine, a nutrient the thyroid and the developing brain depend on, and a new study warns that British teenage girls would pay the steepest price. More than half already fall short of the recommended amount, and that share could climb to 80 percent if they gave up dairy entirely.
Researchers from the University of Surrey, Queen’s University Belfast, and University College Dublin, writing in The Lancet Planetary Health, built a model using national UK dietary data and real product labels from plant-based milks, yogurts, and cheeses sold in supermarkets. They tested what happens when people replace dairy with plant versions at levels drawn from major sustainability recommendations, including the UK’s Net Zero plan and the EAT-Lancet Commission’s guidelines. Even replacing just a third of dairy measurably cut iodine, with young children, teenagers, and women of childbearing age hit hardest.
Iodine’s path into the food supply comes down to a quirk. Dairy products naturally pick up iodine through cattle feed supplements and disinfectants used in milking equipment, but most plant-based alternatives have no built-in source and aren’t required to add it back in. As climate guidelines push people toward oat milk lattes and cheese substitutes, that under-the-radar source of iodine is quietly disappearing.
How Scientists Modeled the Plant-Based Milk Swap
To figure out what would happen if people cut back on dairy, the team used detailed food diary data from more than 3,500 people across the UK, ages 1.5 to 100, drawn from the National Diet and Nutrition Survey. They focused on the 87 percent of participants, roughly 3,100 people, who reported eating some dairy, since the modeling needed a starting point of dairy consumption to replace.
From there, researchers digitally swapped out milk, cheese, and yogurt in each person’s diet for plant-based versions, gram for gram, at four levels: 20 percent, 35 percent, 50 percent, and a full 100 percent replacement. These numbers weren’t random. They reflect sustainability recommendations from the UK Climate Change Committee and the EAT-Lancet Commission, including targets for reducing animal-based food consumption. Nutrient levels for the plant-based products came from an earlier market survey of real items sold in UK grocery stores, capturing how much, or how little, iodine, calcium, vitamin B2, and vitamin B12 those products actually contain.
Four scenarios went into the model. One reflected today’s mostly voluntary approach to fortifying plant-based products. Another tested a policy requiring all plant-based dairy alternatives to be fortified with iodine and other nutrients. A third examined what would happen if bread, a food nearly everyone eats, were made with salt with added iodine instead of regular salt. A final scenario combined both fortification policies.
Source : https://studyfinds.com/full-dairy-to-plant-milk-swap-could-push-teen-girls-iodine-gap-to-80/

