Scientists have long tied intelligence to big brains, and a bumble bee’s brain is tiny. Fewer than a million neurons are enough for the insect to solve problems it has never faced, learn a skill by watching a nestmate, and pick up that nestmate’s apparent optimism. That is what a new perspective article in the journal Science lays out, written by Lars Chittka of Queen Mary University of London and Stanley Heinze of Lund University in Sweden.

Humans and chimpanzees are the usual examples of sophisticated thinking. Bumble bees were never expected to join them. Chittka and Heinze review recent experiments that put that expectation to the test. As a perspective piece, the article summarizes earlier studies instead of reporting a new experiment, so there is no single group of bees to count.
That raises the authors’ central question: what is the smallest amount of brain that can produce real intelligence? Bees make a useful test case, because they pull off feats once linked to much larger brains.
Bumble Bee Intelligence Shows Up in Ball-Rolling Problem-Solving
One experiment placed bees in a container with a ceiling too low for controlled flight. Artificial flowers filled with nectar sat on the ceiling’s underside, out of reach. The only route to a drink was to move a ball into position and climb on top of it. Bees could even direct the ball toward a goal location that had stopped being visible.
A classic chimpanzee experiment follows the same logic, with a banana hung out of reach and boxes the animals moved to climb up to it. Chittka and Heinze read the results as goal-directed problem-solving, evidence that insects can flexibly use what they have learned on a brand-new problem.
Some Bumble Bees Learn Multistep Skills by Watching Nestmates
Other experiments used puzzle boxes with latches that had to be moved in the correct order to reach nectar, a bit like a combination lock. No bee solved the puzzle without the chance to watch another bee first. But some untrained bees that observed a skilled demonstrator eventually opened the box themselves.
Picking up a skill too difficult to discover alone, purely by watching, has been documented only in humans and chimpanzees besides bumble bees, according to the authors. Copying a peer’s know-how does not appear to require a big primate brain.
Optimism-Like Moods Spread Between Bumble Bees by Sight Alone
A third experiment tested something closer to mood. After an unexpected reward, bees appeared to settle into an upbeat state. They then treated a vague signal, one that might or might not promise food, as more likely to be good news, much like a person who sees a glass as half full.
Other bees that simply watched an upbeat nestmate through a clear partition began making the same hopeful call. No food passed between the bees, and no chemical cues were involved, so sight alone carried the effect, much as a coworker’s good mood can rub off.
Chittka and Heinze stay cautious about what that means. Spreading moods is “only a basic component of empathy,” they write, and alternative explanations for these results are still debated. Even so, finding it in an insect hints that some ways of passing along internal states may be “evolutionarily widespread.”
Bumble Bee Intelligence May Trace to Memory and Navigation Circuits
Two regions of the bee brain stand out. One is a memory center called the mushroom body, which links a smell, sight, or sound to something good or bad. A bumble bee has roughly 50 times more of this region’s key cell type than a fruit fly does, leaving room for many separate memories to coexist without interfering. The authors compare its layout to the hippocampus, a memory region in mammals.
A second region handles steering. It compares the direction a bee is heading with where it wants to go and corrects course when the two do not match. Fruit flies have a similar setup, but bumble bees carry extra circuits that could let them keep track of many routes at once, which may help when picking the best path among several flowers. Bees may not have needed entirely new brain machinery, either. Evolution may have simply expanded ancient insect circuits, and higher thinking may have evolved many times.
Those circuit ideas remain unproven, and testing them depends on a connectome, a complete map of how a brain’s cells connect. One already exists for the fruit fly, whose brain holds about 140,000 neurons. Only a few regions of the bumble bee brain have been mapped, though current technology could put a whole-brain map within a decade’s reach. Comparing species could show which wiring differences explain more flexible behavior.
Source: https://studyfinds.com/bees-iq-doesnt-need-big-brains/

